Members of Syrian civil society engage high level officials, including President Volodymyr Zelensky, as well as key Ukrainian stakeholders, in Kyiv, to commemorate the 10th Anniversary of the Chemical Weapon attacks on Ghouta.

Aug 25, 2023    |                       |   Download as PDF   |   This post is also available in: Arabic

On the 10th anniversary of the 2013 chemical attacks on Ghouta in Syria, and in calling for accountability for ongoing war crimes in Ukraine emboldened by the impunity for past and ongoing crimes in Syria, a group of Syrian civil society representatives visited Kyiv for a series of high-level official meetings and discussions with civil society leaders that concluded with an engagement at the Third Summit of the Crimea Platform with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Members of the delegation:
• Attended the Third Summit of the Crimea Platform, where representatives of states from across the world, including heads of states, delivered messages of solidarity with Ukraine. Members of the delegation engaged with President Zelensky at the Summit, delivering a message of solidarity for the fight against
impunity in Ukraine and Syria. They affirmed that the free people of Syria stand against crimes committed in Ukraine and stand with its people, contrary to the Syrian regime’s support to Russia. The delegation presented President Zelensky with two gifts. The first symbolises forced displacement and the use of
chemical weapons in Syria using the colors of Ukrainian flag, which was hand made in Syria by artist and chemical weapons survivor, Akram Abo Alfoz. The second is a helmet of a fallen volunteer from the White Helmets who was killed in Syria, representing the sacrifice of Syrian heroes in the face of war crimes
committed by the Syrian regime in its Russian allies.

• Had an official meeting with Prosecutor General, Andriy Kostin, and his team responsible for different war crimes, international collaboration, and victims. Mr Kostin delivered strong messages of solidarity and recognition of the chemical attack. All members of the Syrian delegation shared their messages with Mr Kostin, expressing unwavering solidarity with Ukraine’s fight against impunity for crimes committed by Russia, by showcasing Russia’s propensity to commit such crimes as a policy using its actions in Syria as damning evidence. Technical and advocacy collaboration methods were discussed. The delegation presented Mr Kostin with a symbolic gift from Syria.

• Met with Tamila Tasheva, Permanent Representative of the President of Ukraine in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, Ukraine, and Maria Tomak, the Head of the Crimea Platform Department. The meeting reasserted the solidarity between the two people and the call for freedom from authoritarian regimes.

• Met with Oleksandra Matviichuk,head of the 2022 Nobel Laureate Center for Civil Liberties. The delegation discussed efforts of civil society organisation in pursuing justice and accountability for both countries.

• Visited the large graveyard in the church of Bucha and met with the Father Andriy. The delegation paid tribute for the victims of the massacre that was committed by the Russian army in Bucha which led to the killing of around 458 civilians in February 2022. Father Andriy expressed his gratitude for the visit, recalling that Syrians know well what Ukrainians are going through.

• Visited the relocated Mariupol hospital in Kyiv. The doctors of this hospital miraculously escaped the occupation in Mariupol which had experienced the systematic attacks by Russian air and land forces. As kind of resistance this hospital was re-established in Kyiv to until they will be able to go back home. Doctors and members of the Syrian delegation who were subjected to the same Russian policy, and who advocate against the bombing of hospitals, stood with them side by side.

• Had a heartfelt exchange with families of forcibly disappeared persons and political prisoners kidnapped and detained by Russia. During which, personal experiences and learned lessons from Syria and Ukraine were shared as a basis for a joint solidarity campaign demanding justice for all political detainees around the world.

• Met with leading and award-winning Ukrainian Journalist Nataliya Gumenyuk from The Reckoning Project and Public Interest Journalist Lab. Ms Gumenyuk previously covered the Arab Spring, including the fall of Aleppo. The delegation exchanged views on building public solidarity between Syrians and Ukrainians. The delegation presented Ms Gumenyuk with a token of appreciation from Syria for her efforts in supporting the trip.

• Visited the Independence Square of Kyiv, which was a key location for Ukrainian’s resistance against past authoritarian regimes. The delegation renewed its commitment to continue the fight towards a democratic Syria, premised on the rule of law and human rights.

Raed Al Saleh, the head of the White Helmets, said: “Since its intervention in Syria to support the Assad regime, Russia has continued to violate the rules of international humanitarian law, targeting infrastructure and humanitarian workers, employing a policy of collective punishment, destroying and besieging cities, and pursuing a policy of disinformation. These brutal tactics are now being applied in Ukraine. Justice must be pursued with such insistent and unwavering determination that no dictator or nation believes they can escape consequences for committing atrocities and abuses without accountability.”

Taher Hijazi, a human rights defender and recipient of the Marianne award for human rights who survived and documented chemical attacks in Syria said: “Ten years ago, I was responding to and documenting the evidence of the Russian-supported chemical attack in Ghouta. Today, I am here to back the foremost efforts of our Ukrainian colleagues in holding Russia accountable for its continuous war crimes.”

Waad AlKateab, an award-winning Syrian film maker, said: “I’ve been documenting attacks on hospitals and health workers, which has been a Russian military strategy in Syria to destroy the resilience of the entire community; and the same strategy is being repeatedly used in Ukraine. We are here to prove that they have not won in breaking our will, and they won’t. We are here to keep fighting for justice and accountability”.

Fadel Abdlhgani, the head of the Syrian Human Rights Network, said: “In this visit, I handed a list of more than seven thousand of Syrian victims killed by Russian military. We are here to honour them and all Ukrainian victims through our support to the Ukrainians in their accountability efforts against Russia war crimes. Holding perpetrators accountable requires us to join efforts for justice.”

Afraa Hashem, campaigner at The Syria Campaign and a displaced activist from eastern Aleppo, said: “I am a human rights defender who was forcibly displaced with my 3 kids by the Syrian regime and its Russian allies. This crime, which I will never overcome its consequences, was presented by Russia as a process of humanitarian evacuation, when in fact it was one of their war tactics to control my city. I am here to support the Ukrainian families in their fight to reach justice and live safely in their homes.”

The visit was Syrian initiated, led, and funded. It was organised by Madaniya and the Syrian British Consortium at the initiative of Syrian British lawyer Ibrahim Olabi. It was made possible with the support of the White Helmets, the Syrian Network for Human Rights, the Syrian Legal Development Programme, the American Coalition for Syria, the Syria Campaign, the Syrian British Medical Society, Action for Sama, the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria, and Don’t Suffocate the Truth Campaign. It was facilitated by kind support of the Office of the Prosecutor General Official Protocol in Ukraine and with the assistance of The Reckoning Project: Ukraine Testifies.

LIST OF DELEGATION

• Abdulkarim Ekzayez: Health system and health security specialist at King’s College London. He is the general secretary of the Syrian British Medical Society and the deputy chair of the Syrian Public Health Network. He established some of the first field hospitals in northern Syria where he witnessed attacks on hospitals.

• Afraa Hashim: Activist and human rights defender. Campaigner with the Rights group, The Syria Campaign, and a board member of Don’t Suffocate the Truth; an advocacy campaign for combating the denial of chemical attacks in Syria.

• Amneh Khoulani: Human rights defender, vice chair of Madaniya and co-founder of Families for Freedom. She is a recipient of International Women of Courage Award by the US Secretary of State.

• Fadel Abdulghani: Chair of the Syrian Network of Human Rights (SNHR). SNHR’s documentation is referenced in many state’s country reports and rigorously documented Russian abuses in Syria.

• Haytham Alhamwi: Chair of the Syrian British Consortium; a UK-based award-winning Syrian-led group advocating for democracy and accountability, including in relation to Russian war crimes in Syria. The SBC engages regularly with head of states and foreign ministers.

• Ibrahim Olabi (Head of Delegation): Chair of the Syrian Legal Development Programme and a board member of Madaniya and the Syrian British Consortium. He is the Chief Legal Counsel of The Reckoning Project: Ukraine Testifies, and a Barrister at Guernica 37.

• Mazen Gharibah: Executive Director of the award-winning Syrian British Consortium. He is a researcher at London School of Economics and a member of the UN-backed Syrian Constitutional Committee representing the civil society.

• Raed Al-Saleh: Head of the Syria Civil Defense (The White Helmets); A humanitarian organisation dedicated to helping communities in Syria, with more than 3,000 volunteers working to rescue civilians, provide essential services, help civilians settle down, and seek justice for them.

• Salim Namour: Forcibly displaced surgeon from Ghouta, and a survivor and documenter of its chemical attacks. He is the chief of the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria. He was also the founder of the Cave Hospital and the Health Directorate in Ghouta.

• Sawsan Abou Zainedin: Chief Executive Officer of Madaniya; an umbrella of over 200 Syrian civil society organisations working across all sectors and geographies, inside Syria and in diaspora. Madaniya is aimed at enhancing the political agency of the Syrian civic space.

• Taher Hijazi: An award-winning human rights defender who received the Marianne award for human rights. He survived and documented the sarin gas attacks in 2013 and chlorine gas attacks in 2018 on Ghouta and co-founded the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria.

• Waad AlKateab, A Syrian activist and filmmaker. Her first documentary, For Sama, received worldwide critical acclaim, winning numerous awards, including best Documentary at the BAFTAs and an OSCAR nomination at the 2020 Academy Awards. She was listed in the 2020 Time100 List of Most Influential People.

• Zaki Lababidi M.D., Chair of Foreign Affairs at the Syrian American Council; the largest Syrian American grassroots organisation in the U.S. and a board member of the American Coalition for Syria. Dr. Lababidi leads the organisation’s relations with regional partners and counterparts.

No Justice for Torture in Syria: A Victim Rights-Based Analysis of the 2022 Anti-Torture Law

Nov 2, 2023    |                           |   Download as PDF    |   This post is also available in: Arabic

Produced by the International Law Support Unit of The Syrian Legal Development Programme (SLDP) and the Syria Regional Desk of The Diakonia International Humanitarian Law Centre

Published On October 17, 2023

In January 2022, the Koblenz Higher Regional Court held that the Syrian authorities have systematically perpetrated torture and cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment (ill-treatment) in detention centres.(1) Since the uprising in 2011 and the subsequent armed conflict, the Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arabic Republic (COI) has extensively documented the use of torture by the Syrian authorities, particularly the intelligence and security agencies, against civilians, including political opponents and human rights defenders. The COI has also documented the use of torture and ill-treatment by non-State armed groups (NSAGs), such as the Free Syrian Army, the Syrian National Syrian Army, the Syrian Democratic Forces, Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham, and the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant.
State agents responsible have persistently evaded justice, benefiting from structural and legislative obstacles to impartial and independent investigations that have institutionalised impunity. Acts of torture and ill-treatment by NSAGs have also not been investigated or prosecuted. This violates the State’s obligation to investigate allegations of serious violations of International Human Rights Law (IHRL) and International Humanitarian Law (IHL), to prosecute suspected perpetrators, and to provide effective remedies for victims. Consequently, victims and survivors of torture and ill-treatment have been abandoned with no access to remedy, reparations, or recognition of their harm and experiences.
The Syrian authorities have consistently denied allegations of torture and ill-treatment, claiming that detainees are treated humanely and that torture is a crime adequately punishable by law. The Syrian authorities have also alleged that the Convention against Torture (CAT) is part of its domestic legislation and takes precedence over national laws in case of conflict. Yet, despite the Syrian authorities’ claim that domestic laws were already adequate to criminalise torture, they enacted the Anti-Torture Law of 29 March 2022 (hereinafter anti-torture law). While the new law imposes stricter penalties and could be seen as a positive step towards comprehensively criminalising torture in Syria, it cannot be read in isolation from other laws in force, particularly those granting immunity to State agents.
This paper analyses the Syrian authorities’ failure to fulfil its obligations under international law despite the adoption of the new anti-torture law. The paper argues that the new anti-torture law fails to:
– ensure the absolute prohibition of torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment as required by IHRL, IHL, and Syria’s obligations under the CAT.
– explicitly criminalise cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or punishment as stipulated by the CAT, therefore obstructing the recognition of victims of ill-treatment as such before the law and their subsequent access to remedy and justice.
– address enforced disappearance as a form of torture, therefore failing to recognise the specific impact of enforced disappearance on Syrian families and provide redress to victims of enforced disappearance and their families.
– end the impunity enjoyed by members of the Syrian Military and its Intelligence, Internal Security Forces, and the General Intelligence Directorate, therefore violating victims’ right to an investigation and access to judicial remedy.
– provide full and effective redress and reparation for torture victims, including restitution, compensation, rehabilitation, satisfaction and right to the truth, and guarantees of non-repetition.
This paper argues that victims of torture and ill-treatment in Syria will continue to face significant obstacles in pursuing justice and redress in spite of the new anti-torture law. The question of the retroactive application of the law to past allegations of torture raises concerns about shielding perpetrators with further immunity as well as about the adequacy of the law itself to prosecute for those crimes and to redress the victims. Furthermore, the imposition of stricter penalties alone is insufficient to address the systematic use of torture in Syria. More comprehensive measures are needed to address past violations, tackle the root causes of torture, hold perpetrators accountable, provide redress and reparation to victims, and guarantee non-repetition. The new anti-torture law fails to address these critical issues, treating torture as an exception rather than a widespread and systematic policy in Syria.


(1) Koblenz Higher Regional Court, Life imprisonment due to crimes committed against humanity and murder – sentencing of a suspected member of the Syrian secret service (17 January 2022) (Available at:
https://olgko.justiz.rlp.de/presse-aktuelles/detail/life-imprisonment-due-to-crimes-committed-against-humanity-and-murder-sentencing-of-a-suspected-member-of-the-syrian-secret-service).

Members of Syrian civil society engage high level officials, including President Volodymyr Zelensky, as well as key Ukrainian stakeholders, in Kyiv, to commemorate the 10th Anniversary of the Chemical Weapon attacks on Ghouta.

Aug 25, 2023    |   [jp_post_view]   |   Download as PDF   |   This post is also available in: Arabic

On the 10th anniversary of the 2013 chemical attacks on Ghouta in Syria, and in calling for accountability for ongoing war crimes in Ukraine emboldened by the impunity for past and ongoing crimes in Syria, a group of Syrian civil society representatives visited Kyiv for a series of high-level official meetings and discussions with civil society leaders that concluded with an engagement at the Third Summit of the Crimea Platform with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky.

Members of the delegation:
• Attended the Third Summit of the Crimea Platform, where representatives of states from across the world, including heads of states, delivered messages of solidarity with Ukraine. Members of the delegation engaged with President Zelensky at the Summit, delivering a message of solidarity for the fight against
impunity in Ukraine and Syria. They affirmed that the free people of Syria stand against crimes committed in Ukraine and stand with its people, contrary to the Syrian regime’s support to Russia. The delegation presented President Zelensky with two gifts. The first symbolises forced displacement and the use of
chemical weapons in Syria using the colors of Ukrainian flag, which was hand made in Syria by artist and chemical weapons survivor, Akram Abo Alfoz. The second is a helmet of a fallen volunteer from the White Helmets who was killed in Syria, representing the sacrifice of Syrian heroes in the face of war crimes
committed by the Syrian regime in its Russian allies.

• Had an official meeting with Prosecutor General, Andriy Kostin, and his team responsible for different war crimes, international collaboration, and victims. Mr Kostin delivered strong messages of solidarity and recognition of the chemical attack. All members of the Syrian delegation shared their messages with Mr Kostin, expressing unwavering solidarity with Ukraine’s fight against impunity for crimes committed by Russia, by showcasing Russia’s propensity to commit such crimes as a policy using its actions in Syria as damning evidence. Technical and advocacy collaboration methods were discussed. The delegation presented Mr Kostin with a symbolic gift from Syria.

• Met with Tamila Tasheva, Permanent Representative of the President of Ukraine in the Autonomous Republic of Crimea, Ukraine, and Maria Tomak, the Head of the Crimea Platform Department. The meeting reasserted the solidarity between the two people and the call for freedom from authoritarian regimes.

• Met with Oleksandra Matviichuk,head of the 2022 Nobel Laureate Center for Civil Liberties. The delegation discussed efforts of civil society organisation in pursuing justice and accountability for both countries.

• Visited the large graveyard in the church of Bucha and met with the Father Andriy. The delegation paid tribute for the victims of the massacre that was committed by the Russian army in Bucha which led to the killing of around 458 civilians in February 2022. Father Andriy expressed his gratitude for the visit, recalling that Syrians know well what Ukrainians are going through.

• Visited the relocated Mariupol hospital in Kyiv. The doctors of this hospital miraculously escaped the occupation in Mariupol which had experienced the systematic attacks by Russian air and land forces. As kind of resistance this hospital was re-established in Kyiv to until they will be able to go back home. Doctors and members of the Syrian delegation who were subjected to the same Russian policy, and who advocate against the bombing of hospitals, stood with them side by side.

• Had a heartfelt exchange with families of forcibly disappeared persons and political prisoners kidnapped and detained by Russia. During which, personal experiences and learned lessons from Syria and Ukraine were shared as a basis for a joint solidarity campaign demanding justice for all political detainees around the world.

• Met with leading and award-winning Ukrainian Journalist Nataliya Gumenyuk from The Reckoning Project and Public Interest Journalist Lab. Ms Gumenyuk previously covered the Arab Spring, including the fall of Aleppo. The delegation exchanged views on building public solidarity between Syrians and Ukrainians. The delegation presented Ms Gumenyuk with a token of appreciation from Syria for her efforts in supporting the trip.

• Visited the Independence Square of Kyiv, which was a key location for Ukrainian’s resistance against past authoritarian regimes. The delegation renewed its commitment to continue the fight towards a democratic Syria, premised on the rule of law and human rights.

Raed Al Saleh, the head of the White Helmets, said: “Since its intervention in Syria to support the Assad regime, Russia has continued to violate the rules of international humanitarian law, targeting infrastructure and humanitarian workers, employing a policy of collective punishment, destroying and besieging cities, and pursuing a policy of disinformation. These brutal tactics are now being applied in Ukraine. Justice must be pursued with such insistent and unwavering determination that no dictator or nation believes they can escape consequences for committing atrocities and abuses without accountability.”

Taher Hijazi, a human rights defender and recipient of the Marianne award for human rights who survived and documented chemical attacks in Syria said: “Ten years ago, I was responding to and documenting the evidence of the Russian-supported chemical attack in Ghouta. Today, I am here to back the foremost efforts of our Ukrainian colleagues in holding Russia accountable for its continuous war crimes.”

Waad AlKateab, an award-winning Syrian film maker, said: “I’ve been documenting attacks on hospitals and health workers, which has been a Russian military strategy in Syria to destroy the resilience of the entire community; and the same strategy is being repeatedly used in Ukraine. We are here to prove that they have not won in breaking our will, and they won’t. We are here to keep fighting for justice and accountability”.

Fadel Abdlhgani, the head of the Syrian Human Rights Network, said: “In this visit, I handed a list of more than seven thousand of Syrian victims killed by Russian military. We are here to honour them and all Ukrainian victims through our support to the Ukrainians in their accountability efforts against Russia war crimes. Holding perpetrators accountable requires us to join efforts for justice.”

Afraa Hashem, campaigner at The Syria Campaign and a displaced activist from eastern Aleppo, said: “I am a human rights defender who was forcibly displaced with my 3 kids by the Syrian regime and its Russian allies. This crime, which I will never overcome its consequences, was presented by Russia as a process of humanitarian evacuation, when in fact it was one of their war tactics to control my city. I am here to support the Ukrainian families in their fight to reach justice and live safely in their homes.”

The visit was Syrian initiated, led, and funded. It was organised by Madaniya and the Syrian British Consortium at the initiative of Syrian British lawyer Ibrahim Olabi. It was made possible with the support of the White Helmets, the Syrian Network for Human Rights, the Syrian Legal Development Programme, the American Coalition for Syria, the Syria Campaign, the Syrian British Medical Society, Action for Sama, the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria, and Don’t Suffocate the Truth Campaign. It was facilitated by kind support of the Office of the Prosecutor General Official Protocol in Ukraine and with the assistance of The Reckoning Project: Ukraine Testifies.

LIST OF DELEGATION

• Abdulkarim Ekzayez: Health system and health security specialist at King’s College London. He is the general secretary of the Syrian British Medical Society and the deputy chair of the Syrian Public Health Network. He established some of the first field hospitals in northern Syria where he witnessed attacks on hospitals.

• Afraa Hashim: Activist and human rights defender. Campaigner with the Rights group, The Syria Campaign, and a board member of Don’t Suffocate the Truth; an advocacy campaign for combating the denial of chemical attacks in Syria.

• Amneh Khoulani: Human rights defender, vice chair of Madaniya and co-founder of Families for Freedom. She is a recipient of International Women of Courage Award by the US Secretary of State.

• Fadel Abdulghani: Chair of the Syrian Network of Human Rights (SNHR). SNHR’s documentation is referenced in many state’s country reports and rigorously documented Russian abuses in Syria.

• Haytham Alhamwi: Chair of the Syrian British Consortium; a UK-based award-winning Syrian-led group advocating for democracy and accountability, including in relation to Russian war crimes in Syria. The SBC engages regularly with head of states and foreign ministers.

• Ibrahim Olabi (Head of Delegation): Chair of the Syrian Legal Development Programme and a board member of Madaniya and the Syrian British Consortium. He is the Chief Legal Counsel of The Reckoning Project: Ukraine Testifies, and a Barrister at Guernica 37.

• Mazen Gharibah: Executive Director of the award-winning Syrian British Consortium. He is a researcher at London School of Economics and a member of the UN-backed Syrian Constitutional Committee representing the civil society.

• Raed Al-Saleh: Head of the Syria Civil Defense (The White Helmets); A humanitarian organisation dedicated to helping communities in Syria, with more than 3,000 volunteers working to rescue civilians, provide essential services, help civilians settle down, and seek justice for them.

• Salim Namour: Forcibly displaced surgeon from Ghouta, and a survivor and documenter of its chemical attacks. He is the chief of the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria. He was also the founder of the Cave Hospital and the Health Directorate in Ghouta.

• Sawsan Abou Zainedin: Chief Executive Officer of Madaniya; an umbrella of over 200 Syrian civil society organisations working across all sectors and geographies, inside Syria and in diaspora. Madaniya is aimed at enhancing the political agency of the Syrian civic space.

• Taher Hijazi: An award-winning human rights defender who received the Marianne award for human rights. He survived and documented the sarin gas attacks in 2013 and chlorine gas attacks in 2018 on Ghouta and co-founded the Association of Victims of Chemical Weapons in Syria.

• Waad AlKateab, A Syrian activist and filmmaker. Her first documentary, For Sama, received worldwide critical acclaim, winning numerous awards, including best Documentary at the BAFTAs and an OSCAR nomination at the 2020 Academy Awards. She was listed in the 2020 Time100 List of Most Influential People.

• Zaki Lababidi M.D., Chair of Foreign Affairs at the Syrian American Council; the largest Syrian American grassroots organisation in the U.S. and a board member of the American Coalition for Syria. Dr. Lababidi leads the organisation’s relations with regional partners and counterparts.

Joint statement of Syrian and international civil society organizations

Jul 20, 2023    |                       |   Download as PDF   |   This post is also available in: Arabic

Joint Statement of Syrian Civil and International Organizations on the Initiation of Proceedings and the postponement of the public hearings on provisional measures on Acts of Torture in Syria before the International Court of Justice

– We the undersigned Syrian civil society and international organizations applaud the application instituting proceedings on the Application of the Convention against Torture (CAT) against the Syrian regime before the International Court of Justice by the Netherlands and Canada. The initiation of proceedings against the Syrian regime on State Responsibility for acts of torture complements continuing accountability efforts under Universal Jurisdiction. It also paves the path for further recognition of the Syrian regime’s State policy of torture Nevertheless, we express surprise and concern at the -3months postponement of the public hearings on provisional measures given the urgent need to address ongoing violations of the CAT.

– For over four decades, and critically since 2011, the Syrian regime has systematically perpetrated torture and ill-treatment in flagrant violation of the Convention against Torture. In this regard, the Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic previously indicated that “it is extremely rare to find an individual who has been detained by the Syrian regime and has not suffered severe torture”. The application submitted by the Netherlands and Canada reflects the experiences of torture and ill-treatment suffered by civilians at the hands of the Syrian regime, including by addressing specific forms of torture such as sexual violence and enforced disappearance, and referring to the use of chemical weapons as resulting in “severe physical and mental suffering”. On this note, Syrian civil society welcomes the inclusion of enforced disappearance in the case as the first instance in which the responsibility of the Syrian regime for enforced disappearance can be assigned in Court.

– For over a decade, Syrian rights groups and civil society have been at the forefront of documenting violations in Syria and creating opportunities to old the Syrian regime accountable for its crimes. In 2021 and 2022, State officials were found responsible for crimes against humanity of torture before German courts under individual criminal responsibility in the Anwar R. and Eyad A. cases, with an additional case against Alaa M. still ongoing. In 2023, the investigative judges of the Paris Judicial Court ordered the indictment before the Paris Criminal Court of Ali Mamlouk, Jamil Hassan and Abdel Salam Mahmoud for acts of torture, arbitrary detention and enforced disappearance against two Syrian-French nationals killed under torture by the Syrian regime. These cases have confirmed that acts of torture committed in Syria were not acts of lone individuals acting on their own, but, rather, were part of a systemic policy directed, approved and overseen by the highest ranks of the Syrian regime – amounting to crimes against humanity.

– The International Court of Justice can now consider acts of torture committed in Syria under the concept of State Responsibility – this will allow for acts of torture, ill-treatment, enforced disappearance and sexual violence to be directly attributed to Syria as a State entity. This finding can be of utmost importance in countering the normalisation efforts spearheaded by countries, notably from the Arab region and neighbouring countries, and in ddressing the gradual apathy of the international community toward the Syrian regime. It is even more pertinent in light of the ongoing discourse on refugees’ return to Syria and the deportation of Syrian refugees by neighbouring countries and others in violation of the principle of non-refoulement.

– We the undersigned Syrian civil society and international organisations also welcome the opening of public hearings on provisional measures which, first supposed to take place on the 19th and 20th of July, will now take place in October 2023 per the request of the Syrian regime. On this note, we would like to highlight that the Syrian regime has previously manipulated and stalled political and accountability processes to avoid confrontation in relation to human rights abuses committed in Syria Given the urgent and life-preserving nature of the provisional measures for victims of torture, we call on the Court to explain the rationale behind the postponement and re-think this decision. After more than a decade of free reign for torture, victims of torture in Syria cannot wait any longer. Moving forward, we call on the Court and relevant parties to take necessary measures to protect the Case from the Syrian’s regime diversion tactics.

– On this note, given the detrimental impact of the postponement on victims, we call on the Court and relevant parties to take necessary measures to ensure better access to information and more meaningful participation in the upcoming steps by victims and survivors. We welcome the fact that Syrian civil society, victims and the greater Syrian public will be able to follow the proceedings through the live broadcast of the public hearings and direct access to documents and information on the case. However, with case material and the broadcast only being available in English and French, the Court and relevant parties should find more effective ways to ensure full access to information for Syrian civil society and the broader public (for example, by ensuring Arabic-language coverage of the hearings). Lamenting the lack of access to information in previous accountability efforts, we urge the Court and relevant parties to ensure more effective and inclusive access to information and for future accountability initiatives to follow the model set by the Court to ensure similar measures in future justice efforts.

– On the same note, we call on the Netherlands and Canada to ensure more meaningful representation and participation of Syrian civil society, and victims and survivors of torture in the upcoming steps of the proceedings. While the Netherlands/Canada v Syria is an interState dispute, it is important to underline the need to adopt more inclusive and participatory approaches to this justice initiative which has been undertaken on behalf of victims. As a result, we therefore urge for greater access to information on the case and its progress, and in ensuring increasing representation and participation of victims and survivors of torture in the case to the greatest extent feasible ahead of the upcoming hearings in October 2023.

– The initiation of proceedings on acts of torture before the ICJ can confirm what the Syrian people has known for decades: that Syria is a torture State. We welcome the formal initiation of this justice initiative and reiterate that a future of Syria can only be built on the recognition of the experiences of victims and survivors and their rights, and grounded in accountability and justice for crimes committed in the past decades and still ongoing. Lastly, we highlight the urgent and life-preserving role that provisional measures can take in putting an end to the use of torture and suffering of victims, and therefore we call on the Court to put at the center the interests of victims and those who can still be saved.


Civil Society Organizations Urge UN Member States to Vote in Favor of Independent Institution on Missing Persons in Syria

Jun 27, 2023 |                         | Download as PDF   |   This post is also available in: Arabic



At the end of June, the UN General Assembly will be called to vote on a resolution to establish an independent institution to clarify the fate and whereabouts of missing people in the Syrian Arab Republic, a milestone in the international community’s response to the Syrian conflict.

Since 2011, more than 100,000 individuals have gone missing or been forcibly disappeared by Syrian authorities and other parties to the conflict, including armed groups such as ISIL. In 2021, Syrian families and survivors called for the creation of a new independent, humanitarian institution that will focus on victims’ inalienable right to know the truth about their loved ones.

The call to establish such a new institution is supported by the UN Secretary-General, the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, the Working Group on Enforced Disappearances, and the International Committee of the Red Cross.

The independent institution will be the first-ever response to the Syrian conflict to be entirely imagined and developed by Syrian victims and survivors of enforced disappearance and families of missing persons. The efforts made by Syrian families need the broadest and strongest support possible.

We, therefore, call on UN member states to support the families’ right to truth by voting in favor of the resolution. Voting for the resolution will constitute a major step towards bringing long-awaited answers to thousands of families who have been suffering loss and uncertainty.

Progress on this issue is fundamental to families, communities and society as a whole. The international community must extend a hand of practical support and assistance to families and victims in need. The people of Syria deserve no less.

Signatories

Truth and Justice Charter Group

1. Association of Detainees and Missing Persons in Sednaya Prison
2. Caesar Families Association
3. Coalition of Families of Persons Kidnapped by ISIS (Massar)
4. Families for Freedom
5. Ta’afi Initiative
6. General Union of Internees and Detainees
7. Release Me
8. Hevdesti-Synergy Association for Victims
9. Adra Detainees Association
10. Families of Truth and Justice.

Civil Society Organizations

11. Afrin Platform
12. Afro-Middle East Centre
13. Ali Mourad (Academic & Legal Researcher)
14. Amnesty International
15. Anti-Discrimination Centre Memorial Brussels
16. Austausch – For a European Civil Society, Berlin
17. Avaaz
18. Association de Parents et Amis de Disparus au Maroc
19. Building Blocks for Peace Foundation
20. Budapest Centre for Dialogue and Mass Atrocities Prevention
21. Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies (CIHRS)
22. Cameroon O’Bosso
23. CCFD-Terre Solidaire
24. Center for Civilians in Conflict
25. Center for Victims of Torture
26. Centro de Estudios Legales y Sociales (CELS)
27. Child Rights International Network (CRIN)
28. Civic Assistance Committee
29. Collectif des Familles de Disparu.e.s en Algérie (CFDA)
30. Committee of the Families of the Kidnapped and Disappeared in Lebanon (CFKDL)
31. Consortium on Gender, Security and Human Rights
32. Dawlaty
33. Democracia Global
34. Denis Hurley Peace Institute
35. Donde Estan?-Où sont-ils? France
36. Dozana
37. Egyptian Commission for Rights and Freedoms
38. Euro-mediterranean federation against enforced disappearances
39. FIDH – International Federation for Human Rights
40. Finjan
41. Global Centre for the Responsibility to Protect
42. Global Justice Center
43. Global Network of Women Peacebuilders (GNWP)
44. HAKI Africa
45. Heinrich-Böll-Stiftung
46. Human Rights Center “Viasna”
47. Human Rights Solidarity Organisation
48. Human Rights Watch
49. Hurras Network
50. Independent human rights and media project OVD-Info
51. International Alert
52. Institute for Genocide and Mass Atrocity Prevention
53. International Center for Transitional Justice
54. International Partnership for Human Rights (IPHR)
55. International Service for Human Rights (ISHR)
56. Jacob Blaustein Institute for the Advancement of Human Rights
57. Justice and rehabilitation
58. Justice for life
59. Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group
60. Khulumani Support Group
61. Khwendo jirga
62. Legal Action Worldwide
63. Lelun Association for Victims
64. Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan
65. Middle East and North Africa Partnership for the Prevention of Armed Conflict
(MENAPPAC)
66. Montreal Institute for Genocide and Human Right Studies
67. Movement for Democracy, Development and Transparency Cameroon
68. Network of independent Commission for Human rights in North Africa.
69. Nobel Women’s Initiative
70. PAX for Peace
71. Peace Direct
72. Permanent Peace Movement
73. Ras-ALAIN platform
74. Russi contro la guerra
75. Salam For Yemen
76. Solidarity 2020 and Beyond
77. Stand with Syria Japan (SSJ)
78. Syrian American Medical Society (SAMS)
79. Syrian Lawyers Aggregation
80. Syrians for Truth and Justice (STJ) سوريون من أجل الحقيقة والعدالة
81. Syrian Memory Institution (SMI)
82. Syrian Network for Human Rights (SNHR)
83. Syrian Welsh Society
84. TERRE ET LIBERTE POUR ARAUCO
85. The association Syrian Sweden
86. The Syrian Swedish Democratic Network (SSDF)
87. The Day After
88. The Syria Campaign
89. The Syrian Center for Media and Freedom of Expression (SCM)
90. The Syrian Legal Development Programme (SLDP)
91. Truth Hounds
92. VDSH
93. VSI Action4life
94. WANEP NIGER
95. Wheat Olive Platform
96. WILDAF
97. Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF)
98. Women Now for Development
99. Women’s Refugee Commission
100. World Uyghur Congress
101. World Federalist Movement – Canada
102. YouthHubAfrica

Bashar Al-Assad: End Syria Sanctions Programmes!

We, the undersigned Syrian organisations, in Syria and abroad, call upon Bashar al-Assad to end the Syria sanctions programmes immediately. Assad holds the keys to ending the sanctions by engaging genuinely in the political process outlined by in the UN Security Council resolution 2254, ending human rights violations and submitting to the pillars of genuine justice.